PDA

View Full Version : Hawaii to ask Navy to pay for reef repair



CommunityEditor
02-14-2009, 07:20 PM
About 90 minutes after sunset Feb. 5, the cruiser Port Royal was ending its first day back at sea after four months in the shipyard. It was almost quitting time.

The ship had slowed for a few minutes in the clear water about a half-mile off an island runway at Honolulu International Airport so a training team could get into a small boat and ride to nearby Hickam Harbor. With its passengers gone, the 9,600-ton warship could then slip back into its berth at Naval Station Pearl Harbor and tie up for the night.

But that didn’t happen. Instead, the ship ground onto a rocky shoal just off the runway. When the sun came up the next day, it was still there.

Port Royal spent four nights on the rocks, leading to one of the biggest Navy surface salvage jobs in years.

After salvage ships wrenched it free early Monday, the Port Royal had lost several blades from both its screws; its anchors and anchor chains; parts of its sonar dome; and its skipper, Capt. John Carroll, who was relieved of command as soon as the ship made it back.

The Navy is still investigating what caused Port Royal’s grounding and what will become a multimillion-dollar bill for its recovery and repair. But the basics of what it took to free the cruiser after four tries already are clear — an old-school salvage job in which small, powerful vessels strained to pull a large, grounded ship back into safe waters.

John Sargent’s phone started ringing around midnight Feb. 5. The master of the Military Sealift Command salvage ship Salvor was told to assemble his crew of civilian mariners and Navy divers from Mobile Diving and Salvage Unit 1.

Meanwhile, four harbor tugs were assembled off the airport and had tried to free the Port Royal, but the ship wouldn’t budge. After the sun rose the next day, the Salvor cast off its lines for the short trip to the shoal off the Honolulu airport.

Sargent wasn’t sure what to expect. The Port Royal was stuck on rocks parallel to shore; its orientation meant the Salvor crew members couldn’t pull it free the way they usually practiced.

The Salvor is designed to tie up to the end of the grounded ship, sink its de-beaching gear in deeper water, and then use its powerful winches to pull itself and the stranded ship out of the shallows.

A source with close knowledge of the Port Royal salvage job said Navy engineers worried that clawing at the sea floor with de-beaching gear could damage nearby reefs. The source asked not to be named because he was not authorized to discuss the matter. The Navy would not comment on the Port Royal salvage decisions.

Once planners ruled out using the customary de-beaching methods to rescue Port Royal, it meant the Salvor would have to try a “bollard pull” — securing a line to Port Royal’s stern and gunning the engines to try to pull it off the rocks. So, as high tide came in early Feb. 6, the crew tried it.

The chain snapped. The cruiser remained hung up.

Brute force with finesse
For their next try, Navy engineers needed to study how the Port Royal had gone onto the rocks so they could plot the clearest path to tow it out. But according to a Feb. 7 operational report obtained by Navy Times, neither divers nor underwater robots could see details of the shoal or the cruiser’s underside because there was too much sediment. The Port Royal rolled heavily with the waves, churning up a screen of silt.

As a result, the ship was forced to turn off its air conditioning system because it couldn’t draw in enough clear water. With no air conditioning, it couldn’t cool its communication and combat systems, so those had to be shut off.

After two tries, simple brute force wasn’t working. So the Navy tried even more brute force, with a little finesse. It brought in the large, powerful tug Dove for a third try early Feb. 8 to free the Port Royal.

As high tide came in, engineers lined up tugs along the cruiser’s port quarter as Dove and Salvor struggled to pull it aft. They wanted to pivot the Port Royal to swing its stern into deeper water, or at least so the ship was perpendicular to the beach, Pacific Fleet spokesman Capt. Scott Gureck said. The ship didn’t move out of the shallows, but its stern pivoted about 20 degrees out to sea.

As a tug kept the ship steady, engineers with Naval Sea Systems Command set about capitalizing on its new position. They emptied the seawater pumped in to compensate for the fuel Port Royal’s engines had burned. They dropped its anchors and anchor chains onto the sea floor to lighten the bow. They took off 140 members of the ship’s 324-sailor crew.

All together, the Port Royal was about 600 tons lighter as the sun set Feb. 8, when the Dove, Salvor and seven other tugs got into position again. About 2 a.m. the next day, the tide began to come in.

The Navy and commercial harbor tugs took either side of the Port Royal to steady the ship, making sure it didn’t yaw into the rocks as it was towed. The Dove and Salvor were again hooked up to the stern, with the Dove pulling directly astern and the Salvor at a slight angle toward deeper water. The tugs were trying to guide the ship through a deep area MDSU 1 divers had spotted during the day, Sargent said. After several minutes, the cruiser finally began to move. Forty minutes later, it was off the reef.

“I’ve never done anything like this before — it was quite exciting though,” Sargent said. “It was very interesting and we learned a lot.”


Article: http://www.navytimes.com/news/2009/02/navy_portroyal_021409w/

http://i252.photobucket.com/albums/hh23/aliceamm/Military%20Times/021409_navy_portroyal_800.jpg
NAVY
The cruiser USS Port Royal takes a starboard list as the USNS
Salvor tries to free the ship Feb. 9 after it ran aground about a
half-mile south of the Honolulu airport while off-loading person-
nel into a small boat. The Salvor, the Motor Vessel Dove and
seven Navy and commercial tugboats freed Port Royal off a
shoal Feb. 9.

PAMICH
02-17-2009, 09:36 AM
Now here is something worth blogging about. A bad situation that turned out to be a class act of teamwork and planning. Now why they just jettisoned the anchors and chain into the depths has me stumped. It's going to be tougher now to recover them (if they are). The P.R. must have been cruising at a good clip to run the entire ship a ground.

MPLisa
02-17-2009, 02:05 PM
It IS good that teamwork got them off the shoal, because lack of teamwork got them there!

By the way - did the Navy quite using redlead paint below the water line since I've retired??

Battleshort
02-17-2009, 02:25 PM
It IS good that teamwork got them off the shoal, because lack of teamwork got them there!

By the way - did the Navy quite using redlead paint below the water line since I've retired??

Physics got them on the shoal - 32 Ft draft and 29 ft of H2O. Good job on the removal.

The bottom paint now used is some type of heavy, eco-friendly, anti-fouling paint. It's still red.

Red-lead used to be a primer.

MPLisa
02-17-2009, 03:12 PM
In the photo, the bottom looks blue, though. Am I missing something?

I have an eco-friendly benny-sug (remember those?): Hillary should shut her yap, lots of CO2 there....

blackfox
02-21-2009, 09:43 PM
It is a new special eco friendly paint. Also it protects the hull far better than the old stuff. As far as the team work is concerned good job to all invloved I can't recall a USN ship that stuck before. The only other ncident that comes close was that LST that ran aground during the 90's.

forcedj
02-24-2009, 03:20 PM
It is a new special eco friendly paint. Also it protects the hull far better than the old stuff. As far as the team work is concerned good job to all invloved I can't recall a USN ship that stuck before. The only other ncident that comes close was that LST that ran aground during the 90's.


Which carrier was it that got stuck in San Diego back in the 80s or early 90s? They were returning from deployment and were only yards from their pier. The skipper mustered the entire crew on the flight deck and had them run back an forth in unison in an effort to rock the ship and get it to float free (I think they call that "Sallying the ship" or something like that). But it didn't work. But what ship was that?

Dan

Battleshort
02-24-2009, 03:31 PM
Which carrier was it that got stuck in San Diego back in the 80s or early 90s? They were returning from deployment and were only yards from their pier. The skipper mustered the entire crew on the flight deck and had them run back an forth in unison in an effort to rock the ship and get it to float free (I think they call that "Sallying the ship" or something like that). But it didn't work. But what ship was that?

Dan

Enterprise. In SF bay. My ship had just spent the last 5 1/2 months plane-guarding these guys. We laughed our asses off when we heard the news.

MPLisa
02-27-2009, 12:35 AM
In the movie "Bridges at Toko Ri", the CV skipper uses the thrust of the piston-engined planes on the flight deck to help maneuver the ship to the pier. Not sure if it was in the book or not, or even a real event, but, given Michener's knowledge of the Navy, it might have been from a real incident.

forcedj
02-27-2009, 09:35 AM
In the movie "Bridges at Toko Ri", the CV skipper uses the thrust of the piston-engined planes on the flight deck to help maneuver the ship to the pier. Not sure if it was in the book or not, or even a real event, but, given Michener's knowledge of the Navy, it might have been from a real incident.

Having been PCS to three different carriers, I can tell you that there are in fact contingency plans written up that call for using tied down jet aircraft in this manner. It’s not going to give you much in terms of headway, but if you loose steering it would allow you to maneuver the ship.

Dan

MPLisa
02-27-2009, 05:32 PM
Hmmmmmm, interesting.

Sabrina76
02-28-2009, 06:52 PM
Now why they just jettisoned the anchors and chain into the depths has me stumped. It's going to be tougher now to recover them (if they are).

Salvor was my first ship. Back then is was still USS vice USNS. At one point we had to recover an anchor and ten shots of anchor chain for a ship that use to be in Hawaii, when they dropped it all while trying to anchor off HIA's runway. Generally the same area PR ran aground at. We happened to be anchored a couple hundred yards away when it happened. We just pulled anchor and headed over. From the time we pulled anchor, to us craning it onto the pier was about 18 hours. Since PR dropped it while aground in an attempt to lighten her load for a possible float off the reef, the anchors will be sitting with the chain piled right on top of them. Chances are the chain won't be tangled within itself and believe it or not, it will make it easier to recover. You start with the bitter end of the anchor chain and pull it up on deck. Between USNS Salvor and MDSU-1 they can have both anchor's and chain on the pier in three days, and that's with taken rest time between getting each anchor.

CommunityEditor
03-02-2009, 11:51 PM
The state of Hawaii plans to ask the Navy to reimburse it for the cost of repairing the coral reef damaged when the cruiser Port Royal ran aground Feb. 5.

The state Department of Land and Natural Resources announced Friday it will know the approximate cost of the repair job after it finishes an assessment of how much reef was damaged; how much has already been repaired by state and Navy divers; and how much work remains.

The state’s divers will need about another week to finish inspecting the reef, according to the announcement. They and Navy divers from Mobile Diving and Salvage Unit 1 have been measuring and photographing the reef since the Port Royal struck it.

The divers also have been gluing coral back to the reef with quick-setting cement and pulling off “non-salvageable pieces” and dropping them in deeper water, according to the state announcement. “If not done,” it said, non-salvageable pieces “may cause secondary damage to the surrounding coral reef during heavy swells.”

Gluing broken coral pieces back onto a main reef is a common rescue process for reefs that have been damaged by groundings, said Lisa DiPinto, an injury assessment coordinator with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. If the live pieces can be replaced on the main reef quickly enough, they have a good chance of staying alive.

The Port Royal went hard aground on the reef after nightfall Feb. 5 as it was stopped or making slow speed to transfer ship-riders to a small boat. It took three days, four tries and nine tugs and salvage ships to pull the ship free. During the time it spent grounded on the reef, Port Royal suffered heavy damage as it rolled back and forth with the waves. Navy inspectors are now examining the ship in dry dock.


Article: http://www.militarytimes.com/news/2009/03/navy_reef_claim_030209w/