PDA

View Full Version : 2 recruiting bosses fired after suicide probe



CommunityEditor
12-23-2008, 07:32 PM
HENDERSON, Texas — Sgt. 1st Class Patrick Henderson, a strapping Iraq combat veteran, spent the last, miserable months of his life as an Army recruiter, cold-calling dozens of people a day from his strip-mall office and sitting in strangers’ living rooms, trying to sign up their sons and daughters for an unpopular war.

He put in 13-hour days, six days a week, often encountering abuse from young people or their parents. When he and other recruiters would gripe about the pressure to meet their quotas, their superiors would snarl that they ought to be grateful they were not in Iraq, according to his widow.

Less than a year into the job, Henderson — afflicted by flashbacks and sleeplessness after his tour of battle in Iraq — went into his backyard shed, slid the chain lock in place, and hanged himself with a dog chain.

He became, at age 35, the fourth member of the Army’s Houston Recruiting Battalion to commit suicide in the past three years — something Henderson’s widow and others blame on the psychological scars of combat, combined with the pressure-cooker job of trying to sell the war.

“Over there in Iraq, you’re doing this high-intensive job you are recognized for. Then, you come back here, and one month you’re a hero, one month you’re a loser because you didn’t put anyone in,” said Staff Sgt. Amanda Henderson, herself an Iraq veteran and a former recruiter in the battalion.

The Army has 38 recruiting battalions in the United States. Patrick Henderson’s is the only one to report more than one suicide in the past six years.

The Army began an investigation after being prodded by Amanda Henderson and Texas Sen. John Cornyn. Cornyn, a Republican on the Armed Services Committee, said he will press for Senate hearings.

“We need to get to the bottom of this as soon as we can,” he said.

The all-volunteer military is under heavy pressure to sign up recruits and retain soldiers while it wages two wars.

Douglas Smith, a spokesman for the Army Recruiting Command, acknowledged that recruiting is a demanding job but said counseling and other support are available.

“I don’t have an answer to why these suicides in Houston Recruiting Battalion occurred, but perhaps the investigation that is under way may shed some light on that question,” he said.

In all, 15 of the Army’s 8,400 recruiters have committed suicide since 2003. During that period, more than 540 of the Army’s half-million active-duty soldiers killed themselves.

The 266-member Houston battalion covers a huge swath of East Texas, from Houston to the Arkansas line. Henderson committed suicide Sept. 20. Another battalion member, Staff Sgt. Larry Flores Jr., hanged himself in August at age 26; Sgt. Nils “Aron” Andersson, 25, shot himself to death in March 2007; and in 2005, a captain at battalion headquarters took his life, though the military has not disclosed any details. All served combat tours before their recruiting assignments.

Charlotte Porter, Andersson’s mother, said her son — who served two tours in Iraq with the 82nd Airborne and earned a Bronze Star — couldn’t lie to recruits about the war and felt an enormous burden to ensure they could become the kind of soldiers he would want watching his back.

“He wasn’t a complainer. He just said it really sucked,” said his 51-year-old mother, who is from Eugene, Ore. “He felt like a failure.”

Paul Rieckhoff, founder of the advocacy group Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America, said recruiting these days “is arguably the toughest job in the military.”

“They’re under incredible stress. You can see it on their faces,” he said.

In Iraq, Henderson helped lead other infantrymen on risky “snatch-and-grab” missions and saw several buddies die.

He had been stationed in Germany before going to Iraq. After his tour was up, he was assigned to recruiting. He didn’t particularly want to leave the infantry, but going to recruiting allowed him to move back to the U.S., his widow said.

Like most recruiters, he began his day with paperwork, followed by cold calls to high school graduates and college students. He spent lunches trying to chat up high schoolers outside the cafeteria, and then, more phone calls — often 150 a day, according to his widow.

He spent evenings on the living room sofas or at the dining room tables of the few interested young people, trying to sell them and their families on the Army’s opportunities while easing their fears. Some recruits’ parents were hostile.

“They are completely outright nasty to you. That’s stressful to you right then and there because you have some mother or father just ripping you apart,” Amanda Henderson said.

She said her husband also found himself under crushing pressure from above. He and other recruiters in the battalion were required to account for every minute of every day in planners and logs, his widow said.

When Henderson took some time to recover from knee surgery, his bosses acted as if he was lazy and threatened to have him thrown out of recruiting and reassigned far from his wife, Amanda Henderson said.

He lived in constant fear of failing to sign up enough people, something that can result in an all-day audit by a recruiter’s superiors and thwart a soldier’s chances of a promotion, Amanda Henderson said.

As much as Henderson hated recruiting, he did the job well, his widow said. But Flores, who killed himself a few weeks before Henderson, “was getting chewed up one side and down the other” at work in the days before he died, Amanda Henderson said. Flores was her boss.

Smith, the Army spokesman, would not comment on Henderson’s job performance. Asked about the demands put on recruiters by their superiors, he said recruiting duty “often does entail long hours during the week and on weekends.” But he added: “There are other duty assignments in the Army that entail long hours, such as being deployed.”

Some recruiters volunteer for the job, but most are assigned. They must have a recent evaluation showing no record of mental instability. But Amanda Henderson said her husband, like other combat veterans, rushed through his assessment, insisting he was fine.

Patrick Henderson had been out of Iraq a little less than a year when he began recruiting, and after several months on the job, his sleeplessness and flashbacks became evident, according to his wife. She said she stayed up one night watching him apparently flash between nightmares of combat and of illegally signing up a recruit.

He suffered a breakdown in the weeks before his suicide, his wife said. Because he was hundreds of miles from the nearest Army post, he went to a local counselor recommended by the military after an initial visit with an Army doctor. But the counselor had never worked with a combat veteran and couldn’t decipher the military jargon in his medical records, Amanda Henderson said.

One morning in September, she woke up alone, panicked and went out to look for her husband. The chain was on the door to the shed, but she could see him inside. She pried the window open, and screamed. “He was gone,” she said, her voice breaking.

“I don’t want anybody to feel this pain that I have,” she said, her eyes welling with tears. “It’s too much for one person. They need help.”


Article: http://www.militarytimes.com/news/2008/12/ap_recruiter_suicides_122208/

mel44
12-23-2008, 07:56 PM
There is not words to put here. I have had 2 personally here at Ft. Campbell since 04. I cant state enough the importance of re-deployment/reintegration information for spouses and family. Sometimes it seems silly that a website forum should be of any consequence but here at Ft. Campbell we have 1 civilian psychologist with a open practice. The army has many wonderful and useful programs but most of the young soldiers are afraid to seek help until its to late and their symptoms have become so evident that they are discharged. Communities like ours get so many of these young people. They cant sleep, they are tormented by symptoms they don’t understand and are afraid to tell anyone but they can do it here where they are safe. We never know if that next "hello my name is" could be that persons last attempt at reaching out. What a powerful tool this can be.

CommunityEditor
01-22-2009, 09:35 PM
SAN ANTONIO —Sen. John Cornyn on Thursday called for a congressional hearing on suicides among Army recruiters, saying a recent group of deaths in an East Texas battalion show the strain on an all-volunteer force fighting two wars.

While an Army investigation attributed the four suicides over three years in the Houston Recruiting Battalion to a combination of work environment, stress and personal issues, Cornyn said investigators found the Army was violating its own regulations by pressuring recruiters to meet individual recruiting goals that are higher than allowed.

“As you might imagine, corners might have been cut — and they were — given the exigency of recruiting for war,” Cornyn said in a conference call with reporters. “The concern is that this is not isolated to a single battalion.”

Cornyn asked the Senate Armed Services Committee to schedule a hearing to address the strain recruiters are under to fill an all-volunteer force during wartime. Family members of some of the recruiters who committed suicide have complained that the isolating high-stress job crushed combat-veteran recruiters.

Four members of the 266-member battalion that covers most of East Texas have committed suicide since 2005. Nationwide, 15 recruiters have committed suicide since 2003; the Houston battalion was the only one to report more than one.

Cornyn’s call came one day after the Army announced it had completed an investigation into the deaths.

Brig. Gen. Frank Turner III concluded in the 2½-month investigation that the Texas deaths were caused by a combination of factors. A call to an Army spokesman for details on the recruiting goals policy was not immediately returned Thursday.

Cornyn, who was briefed on the investigation, said at least one recruiter had been humiliated by the command and all had some personal relationship problems.

On Feb. 13, all recruiters and commanders will suspend their recruiting duties for training and discussions on how to improve the command.

The Army is also reviewing recruiter screening and selection processes, provisions for soldiers needing mental health care and access to care and support groups for recruiters who are often isolated far from Army posts.

Charlotte Porter, the mother of recruiter Sgt. Nils “Aron” Andersson, said the actions are good steps forward. Andersson committed suicide in March 2007.

“There’s so much pain still,” she said. “It’s not only the Army that’s going to have to take a stand. Other people are going to have to take a stand. These young men fought for our rights to speak out. When they come home, we have to find a way to listen.”


Article: http://www.militarytimes.com/news/2009/01/ap_cornyn_recruiters_suicides_012209w/

acesfilter
01-22-2009, 09:52 PM
Recruiting is easily one of the most difficult jobs in the Army. It's no wonder this is becoming epidemic.

I recently ran into a recruiter friend of mine. He was telling me how in one year, he only processed 11 Soldiers into the Army (that's less than 45% the desired quota per month). Humiliation tactics used to inspire performance sounds pretty dysfunctional to me. Let us hope the suicide rule for life insurance is waived based on these moral violations.

mel44
01-22-2009, 09:57 PM
Straight up!!!! These men seem to be going into these positions right after returning from deployments in the attempt to avoid further deployments and then having such a high stress job. My Co-Leader for the FRG and her husband have made this choice. They filled me in at the homcoming celebration. I worry about them. He just wants to see his grow up a little but at what cost? There has to be a different answer.

OIFCOMBATVETNYC
01-29-2009, 05:51 PM
Officials: Army suicides at 3-decade high
Buzz Up Send
Email IM Share
Digg Facebook Newsvine del.icio.us Reddit StumbleUpon Technorati Yahoo! Bookmarks Print By PAULINE JELINEK, Associated Press Writer Pauline Jelinek, Associated Press Writer – 1 hr 12 mins ago
Featured Topics: Barack Obama Presidential Transition Photo:Graphic shows active duty Army suicides from 1990 to 2008; 1 c x 3 7/8 in; 46.5 AP WASHINGTON – Suicides among U.S. soldiers rose last year to the highest level in decades, the Army announced Thursday. At least 128 soldiers killed themselves in 2008. But the final count is likely to be considerably higher because 15 more suspicious deaths are still being investigated and could also turn out to be self-inflicted, the Army said.

A new training and prevention effort will start next week. And Col. Elspeth Ritchie, a psychiatric consultant to the Army surgeon general, made a plea for more U.S. mental health professionals to sign on to work for the military.

"We are hiring and we need your help," she said.

The new suicide figure compares with 115 in 2007 and 102 in 2006 and is the highest since record keeping began in 1980. Officials calculate the deaths at a rate of roughly 20.2 per 100,000 soldiers — which is higher than the adjusted civilian rate for the first time since the Vietnam War, officials told a Pentagon news conference.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090129/ap_on_go_ca_st_pe/army_suicides

lmcnair
02-03-2009, 07:57 PM
The Army as an whole can do questionable things. Why would you send someone out of one hot zone into another hot zone? Recruiters are not welcomed in our high schools. Young girls are accussing recruiters everyday of inappropriate behavior. Sometime, it's not the recruiters fault. Recruiters are stretched so thin, they don't have time to spend with their families. Our soldiers as a whole don't want the label mental health attached to their name. We need to start focusing on our soldier's well-being, instead of the numbers every month. Higher-up need to get their heads out of their ass and fix the problem.

CommunityEditor
03-08-2009, 03:43 PM
Two leaders of the Houston Recruiting Battalion have been replaced and disciplinary actions may be possible up to brigade level after an investigation into the suicides of four soldiers in the battalion.

Lt. Col. Toimu Reeves, the battalion commander, and Command Sgt. Maj. Cheryl Broussard have been replaced, according to officials at Accessions Command. Reeves had left in a normal rotation and Broussard was removed from her job, officials said.

“The chain of command is in the process of taking disciplinary actions,” Lt. Gen. Benjamin Freakley, the chief of Accessions Command, said Feb. 25.

In his investigation, Brig. Gen. Del Turner, deputy commanding general of Accessions Command and the officer appointed to conduct the review, recommended disciplinary action against brigade-level commanders, but officials did not provide any details on how many leaders or who might be affected, nor did they discuss what type of action might be taken.

Lt. Col. Mike Bottiglieri took command of the battalion Oct. 3. He was not previously assigned to the battalion.

Bottiglieri is “making some great changes” and working hard to ensure his soldiers have a positive, affirming command climate, Freakley told Army Times. He did not say what kinds of changes are under way.

Master Sgt. Steve Jansen, the senior operations noncommissioned officer for the recruiting battalion, is now the acting command sergeant major, Freakley said.

He added that leaders at Accessions and Recruiting commands want to give the new leadership at least six months in their jobs.

“Then [we’ll] take a look to determine if we have rectified those findings we had in the investigation,” he said.

Turner’s investigation found poor command climate, failing personal relationships and long, stressful work days were factors in the suicides.

In his findings, released Jan. 21, Turner noted a “threatening” environment in the battalion. The report was not released at the time because officials said it contained extensive personal information about the four soldiers who had killed themselves.

A redacted version of Turner’s report was released in mid-February, and it shows that Capt. Rico Robinson, the battalion personnel officer, shot himself between Jan. 15-18, 2005; Staff Sgt. Nils Aron Andersson, a recruiter detailed to one of the battalion’s recruiting stations, shot himself in March 2007; Sgt. 1st Class Larry G. Flores, a recruiting station commander, hanged himself in his home Aug. 8, 2008; and Sgt. 1st Class Patrick Henderson, a recruiter assigned to a recruiting station, hanged himself Sept. 20, 2008.

Turner’s investigation led Army leaders to order a stand-down for all recruiters Feb. 13.

Attempts by Army Times to contact Reeves and Broussard for comment were unsuccessful.


Article: http://www.armytimes.com/news/2009/03/army_recruiting_030709w/

kojack
03-08-2009, 03:56 PM
Im glad at least the CSMs are starting to be relieved of command since they now "share" command with the officer.

Its a shame and a crime this happened. Perhaps if the inept generals were as concerned about caring for their officers and NCOS as they are as having illegal change of command ceremonies for E9s, this wouldnt have happened. It just seems like it grows worse monthly....