PDA

View Full Version : Coast Guard stands by Sept. 11 drill in D.C.



CommunityEditor
09-11-2009, 06:39 PM
WASHINGTON — A routine Coast Guard training exercise set off a panic Friday morning when a member of the public overheard parts of a training drill on a Coast Guard radio channel, Coast Guard officials said.

Whether that person called police — or just the media — is not clear, but Coast Guard officials said there were no shots fired and no suspicious vessel. A CNN report that there were shots fired probably came from a verbalization that service members do during training exercises to simulate gunfire.

“That ‘bang, bang’ was verbalized on the radio,” said Vice Adm. John Currier, chief of staff of the Coast Guard, at a noon news conference. “That’s a normal technique that happens all over the U.S.”

The training exercise, a simulated interdiction of a rogue boater, started at 9:30 a.m. in the vicinity of the 14th Street and Memorial bridges over the Potomac River. The Coast Guard started receiving calls about the exercise at 9:40 a.m., said Cmdr. Ron LaBrec, a Coast Guard spokesman.

The timing set off alarm bells because President Barack Obama was traveling to the Pentagon for a ceremony commemorating the eighth anniversary of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks. Currier said that the president was not near the area at the time.

The Coast Guard did not notify the Secret Service, the Metropolitan Police Department or other law enforcement authorities before the training exercise, because it was a “low-profile, normal training exercise” that is done four times a week by Coast Guard Station Washington, Currier said. That particular area of the river is used because they need a “fairly deep channel” for the boats, he said.

Nevertheless, the FBI temporarily “put a ground hold” on a small number of flights at Reagan National Airport until it received notice that there weren’t any problems, Currier said.

Some expressed disappointment that the Coast Guard did not take into account the 9/11 anniversary when deciding whether to go ahead with the exercise. Brian Wise, executive director of Military Families United, said the fact that the Coast Guard was unaware the exercise would cause alarm was “more indicative of this country not understanding the importance of this day.”

“I fully understand their need for training exercises and support that, but I think this could have been planned another day,” said Wise, who heads up the military family advocacy organization. “I think this was probably an oversight that should be corrected for future years.”

Wise said the organization counts relatives of 9/11 victims and soldiers serving overseas as members.

Currier said he was still gathering details of the exercise because it was approved by Coast Guard Sector Baltimore, not headquarters. LaBrec said there were four 25-foot response boats that would have been manned by four-person crews. The boats are equipped with M-60 machine guns.

Currier said he would do “a top-to-bottom review” on whether the Coast Guard should have scheduled a training exercise on 9/11 and the service’s response both to the incident and the press, but he felt no need to apologize for the event. The service members typically announce at the beginning of the broadcast that they are doing a drill, he said.

“No, I’m not going to issue an apology, because what you are seeing here is a normal training exercise,” Currier said. “This was not ad-libbing by anyone involved.”


Article: http://www.navytimes.com/news/2009/09/coastguard_potomac_exercise_091109w/

CommunityEditor
09-11-2009, 06:41 PM
WASHINGTON— The Coast Guard was conducting a training exercise Friday in the Potomac River moments before President Barack Obama and his motorcade crossed a nearby bridge.

Coast Guard Chief Keith Moore said Friday no shots were fired as part of the exercise. Media reports suggested shots had been fired in the river.

Obama had traveled to the Pentagon for a ceremony commemorating the eighth anniversary of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks.

The Coast Guard put out a statement indicating that media reports “were based on overheard radio calls made over a training frequency.”

“We are still gathering information of how this training event might have been misconstrued as an actual incident. We will conduct a thorough review of this incident.”

There were Coast Guard boats operating in the vicinity of 14th Street and Memorial bridges Friday morning. Whether these were the same boats using the marine radio frequency used for training purposes has not yet been confirmed, according to the statement.

“The best way that we in the Coast Guard can remember Sept. 11 and our security obligations to the nation is to be always ready and this requires constant training and exercise,” the statement said. “To ensure the appropriate readiness posture we conduct training scenarios across the nation on a daily basis.”


Article: http://www.militarytimes.com/news/2009/09/ap_coastguard_potomac_091109w/

blackbeard79
09-12-2009, 11:56 AM
I think the title of the article is misleading. It should read "CNN sets off alarm during Coast Guard training exercise". Basing their reporting on 'scanner chatter' instead of waiting for the facts, they ignited a panic that otherwise wouldn't have existed. As far as conducting the exercise on 9/11, why not? Our enemies don't take days off. Anyone in the military or a first responder knows that the best drills are unannounced and conducted at random intervals, just like the real thing. And the Admiral is right, they best way to pay tribute to those lost on 9/11 is to be ready for the next one.

VFFSSGT
09-13-2009, 10:11 PM
For once, I agree with Robert Gibbs when he condemned CNN for running with scanner traffic....

CommunityEditor
09-18-2009, 07:28 PM
Coast Guard officials are reviewing a Sept. 11 training exercise in the Potomac River that turned into a public relations black eye for the service as well as the media. Despite the outcome, they stand by the decision to drill on the anniversary of the terrorist attacks.

“We train every day,” said Capt. Mark O’Malley, the commanding officer of Sector Baltimore, which oversees Coast Guard Station Washington. “After we examine the issues of communication and notification, there is no reason for us not to do this type of single unit training on 9/11.”

According to CNN, the network’s staff members made two calls to Coast Guard headquarters that didn’t yield any answers, so CNN reported what it had heard on a Coast Guard-marine radio channel and what staffers thought they saw: three Coast Guard boats with mounted machine guns chasing down a rogue boater near Memorial Bridge. The chase took place shortly before President Barack Obama’s motorcade crossed the bridge after a Pentagon ceremony.

“After hearing a further radio transmission about 10 rounds being expended … CNN reported the story,” according to CNN. “Given the circumstances, it would have been irresponsible not to report” what staffers heard and saw.

The fourth boat turned out to be participating in a drill that has taken place on that stretch of the Potomac 12 times since February. The Coast Guard performs drills in that area nearly every day because the water is deeper and there is little commercial traffic, O’Malley said. Coast Guard Station Washington members were practicing nabbing a boater who violated a security zone, he said.

Each scenario lasts three to 10 minutes, said Cmdr. Brian Penoyer, deputy sector commander in Baltimore. The training officer announces the drill on a radio channel reserved for the Coast Guard by the FCC, but can be picked up by radio scanners.

Service members say, “bang, bang,” to indicate shots fired, O’Malley said, adding, “there are no blanks, no flashing, no lights.”

Still, the event drew FBI agents to the scene, and the FAA temporarily stopped departures from Reagan National Airport.

Republican Sens. Susan Collins of Maine and George Voinovich of Ohio, ranking members of the Senate Homeland Security committee, called for a review into the event’s Coast Guard’s timing and its communication with other agencies.

O’Malley said the training was not considered a formal exercise where notification was needed.

Rear Adm. Wayne Justice, 5th District commander, will review the report of the investigation, said Chief Public Affairs Specialist Mike Hvozda.

“He is very committed to making sure this incident does not come to pass again,” Hvozda said.

Transcript
Coast Guard officials say they do not record transmissions over their FCC-designated radio channels, 23A and 81A. CNN, however, released its transcript of the transmission, described as “the excerpted radio scan that was heard in the newsroom”:

• 0:24: You’re approaching a Coast Guard security zone.

• 0:50: You’re in a Coast Guard security zone.

• 1:50: If you don’t stop your vessel, you will be fired upon. Stop your vessel immediately.

• 2:00: If you don’t slow down and stop your vessel, and leave our zone, you will be fired upon.

• 2:18: Still in the zone, still in the zone.

• 2:25: Someone saying: bang, bang, bang.

• 2:35: We have expended 10 rounds, the vessel is operating at stern. We’re going to reassess the situation.

• 3:20: This is the Coast Guard. Have everyone go to the stern. Place your engine in neutral.

• 3:35: _____ out of play, _____ out of play, break scenario, break scenario, break.


Article: http://www.militarytimes.com/news/2009/09/coastguard_drill_091709w/

justanET
09-22-2009, 09:59 PM
this story begs the questions...does the media need to report everything they overhear without verification? When the calls were placed to CGHQ, how long did they wait for a reply before deciding to run the story?

personally, i do not think training should be held up for a holiday or weekend...does anyone remember 07 dec 1941 around 0800ish? Maybe we could ask Mr. I Hate America to only show up when we are ready say between 0900 and 1300, tuesday through thursday but not during lunch or coffee break.

better yet, report on how the CG is training to keep the bad guys at bay, regardless of the time or day...a feel good story that the young BM can tout the accomplishments of training his crew and feels ready to take on the world.

maybe someday the media will start taking responsibility for their actions and admit the failures along with the successes...maybe someday my hair will grow back...