Both Republican presidential front runner Donald Trump and Democratic challenger Bernie Sanders offered the first real look inside their foreign policy teams brain trusts in recent days, giving new attack fodder for their rivals but also a more complete picture of the individuals driving national security discussions in the 2016 campaign.
For the Republicans, those advisers include a heavy dose of longtime party thinkers mixed in with some controversial figures from the most recent wars overseas. For the Democrats, it's a battle between Hillary Clinton's massive team of pro-diplomacy operatives and Sanders' fledgling group of outside experts.
Military Times examined each campaign's core foreign policy team. These names don't comprise the full list of everyone in the room on key security debates. And they don't necessarily identify the individuals who will immediately take up key defense and State Department posts if their candidate becomes commander-in-chief. But they do offer insight on the types of experts the candidates trust, and whether those experts trust them.
Here's an overview:
The names aren't necessarily the individuals who will immediately take up key defense and State Department posts if their candidate becomes commander-in-chief. But they do offer insight on the types of experts the candidates trust, and whether those experts trust them.
Here's a look at some of the notable individuals for each candidate's team:
Key names: Sen. Jeff Sessions, Joseph Schmitz, Keith Kellogg, Carter Page, George Papadopoulos, Walid Phares.
Like the rest of his campaign, Trump's foreign policy team is unconventional. None of the individuals he has highlighted so far have been major players in past Republican presidential campaigns, with many flocking from failed bids by former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and Florida Sen. Marco Rubio.
Retired Army Lt. Gen. Keith Kellogg
Photo Credit: Cubic Corp
Sessions chairs Trump’s foreign policy team, and the Alabama senator brings with him 13 years experience as an Army reservist [[[CAN WE SAY WHAT HE DID IN THE RESERVE? WHAT RANK HE ACHIEVED? I THINK THAT'LL MATTER TO OUR AUDIENCE//A.deG.]]] and 17 years experience on the Senate Armed Services Committee. He currently sits as chairman of that panel’s strategic forces subcommittee, overseeing nuclear, missile defense and intelligence programs.
Kellogg, a retired three-star general, served as the chief operating officer of the Coalition Provisional Authority for about six months in 2003 and 2004, helping lead Iraq's reconstruction and regional stabilization efforts. Since leaving the ranks he has worked for several defense contracting agencies.
Papadopoulos, who had been on neurosurgeon Ben Carson's campaign team, was an analyst at the Hudson Institute focused on energy security changes. Schmitz is a former inspector general for the Defense Department who also worked as an executive with the controversial defense contractor Blackwater.
Key names: Frank Gaffney, Andrew McCarthy, Michael Ledeen, Elliott Abrams, Jim Talent, Jerry Boykin
Gaffney's inclusion on the Texas senator's list of advisers has caused the most criticism. He founded the think tank Center for Security Policy after serving in President Ronald Reagan's Pentagon, but has been harshly attacked for what critics say are anti-Islamic views. The Southern Poverty Law Center has publicly called him "one of America's most notorious Islamophobes" for his accusations of Muslims extremists infiltrating U.S. government agencies.
Boykin, a retired three-star general and former Green Beret commander, is a member of the Family Research Council and received similar criticism for his defense of religious liberty in the ranks and comments about gays and lesbians. He has called the gay rights movement "evil" and said that Christians are being persecuted for not accepting such immoral behavior.
Abrams served in the State Department under Reagan and as a deputy national security adviser to President George W. Bush, and was convicted for withholding information from Congress about arms deals in the Iran-Contra affair. McCarthy is a former U.S. Attorney who led the prosecution of terrorists responsible for the 1993 World Trade Center bombing.
Talent is a retired congressman from Missouri who served on both the House and Senate Armed Services Committees for 12 years. He currently works as a senior fellow specializing in military preparedness at the American Enterprise Institute.
Key names: Richard Allen, Alvin Krongard, William Schneider Jr., Charles King Mallory IV, Trent Lott, Robert McFarlane, George Beebe, Samantha Ravich, Carol Haave
Kasich has touted his own foreign policy experience on the campaign trail, including 18 years on the House Armed Services Committee, and there are a host of former congressional and executive branch notables among his national security advisers. Most of their conservative ties predate the recent wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, by decades.
Allen, who was a chief foreign policy adviser to President Richard Nixon and Reagan before being force to resign for accepting bribes from foreign nationals, leads Kaisch's team. McFarlane served as a Reagan national security adviser during the Iran-Contra affair, Krongard as a CIA director early in George W. Bush's presidency, and Schneider as a former undersecretary of state and defense budget official for much of the 1980s.
The team also boasts six former congressmen: Trent Lott, John Sununu, Pete Hoekstra, Jim Kolbe, Christopher Shays and Bob Walker. All served on defense or appropriations committees during their time in office.
The 25-person team is the only one on the Republican side to prominently feature any women. Ravich was principal deputy national security adviser to Vice President Dick Cheney. Haave worked as a deputy undersecretary of defense for counterintelligence from 2004 to 2008 and led the technology team who created the biometrics identification card system used by troops in Iraq.
Key names: Jake Sullivan, Laura Rosenberger, Derek Chollet, Kathleen Hick, James Miller, Julianne Smith, Wendy Sherman, Jeremy Bash, Rand Beers, Daniel Benjamin, Nicholas Burns
The actual size of Clinton's foreign policy team is unclear, because her years in the Senate and as secretary of State have afforded her time to build up a sizable list of official and unofficial adviseors on a host of security topics.
Photo Credit: Alex Wong/Getty Images
Sullivan, who is her chief adviser in this e area, is a Yale Law School professor who worked as a senior adviser in last year’s Iran nuclear negotiations. Rosenberger served for more than a decade in the State Department and the White House’s National Security Council, with a focus on North Korea and Pacific policy.
Chollet, former assistant defense secretary for international security under President Barack Obama from 2012 to 2014, leads Clinton's Middle East working group with Brookings Institution fellow Tamara Cofman Wittes. Chollet has held a variety of defense and diplomatic posts, including working as the chief speechwriter for United Nations Ambassador Richard Holbrooke, Wittes served as a top Pentagon expert on Middle East affairs from 2009 to 2012 and oversaw the Middle East Partnership Initiative
Several others, including Sherman and Benjamin, worked alongside Clinton at the State Department. Burns actually served there as undersecretary for political affairs during President George W. Bush's term in office.
Key names: Bill French, James Zogby, Larry Korb, Joe Cirincione, Gordon Adams
Sanders foreign policy team has been difficult to pin down. Unlike the other campaigns, he has spoken very little about its members, and actually floated out the names of several individuals before they have been officially brought on to the campaign.
Photo Credit: Lawrence Jackson/AP
That includes Korb, an assistant secretary of defense for Reagan from 1981 to 1985 who now serves as a scholar at the Center for American Progress. Sanders publicly named Korb as a key influencer of his campaign earlier this year, much to Korb's surprise, but a few weeks later invited him on in an official capacity.
Adams, a defense adviser to Al Gore's presidential campaign, was an associate director for national security in the Office of Budget and Management from 1993 to 1997. He is a professor emeritus at American University and frequent media pundit on national security issues.
Zogby, who served as deputy campaign manager to Jesse Jackson's two presidential campaigns in the 1980s, is founder and president of the Arab American Institute.
French, who in recent weeks assumed the lead role in assembling Sanders' national security team, is a policy analyst at the National Security Network. He is by far the youngest prominent foreign policy adviser on any of the campaign staffs, having finished his Masters' degree at the University of Chicago in 2011.
Leo Shane III covers Congress, Veterans Affairs and the White House for Military Times. He can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.