Ask the Lawyer: Will ‘hot’ urinalysis always get you fired?

By

Mathew B. Tully

Q. When can the government not use a hot urinalysis against me?

A. A positive urinalysis spells trouble for any service member who produced it, but such test results will not always turn into government ammunition for court-martial proceedings or administrative actions.

I previously addressed the two main limitations on the use of positive urinalyses in Uniform Code of Military Justice disciplinary proceedings or administrative actions: command-directed examinations and test results from service members who self-referred themselves to a substance abuse program. However, under Department of Defense Instruction 1010.1, the military’s limited-use policy for urinalysis results is broader, and allows for important exemptions.

To recap: A command-directed urinalysis can be ordered “to determine the service member’s competence for duty or the need for counseling, rehabilitation, or other medical treatment when the commander has reason to question the service member’s competence for duty (e.g., aberrant, bizarre, or uncharacteristic behavior; unauthorized absences; violations of safety regulations; breaches of discipline; or other similar behavior).”

Commanders don’t need probable cause to order this type of urinalysis — i.e., they do not have to reasonably believe the test will show an illegal substance is in the service member’s system. Due to this lack of probable cause, the government can’t use the results of a command-directed urinalysis in court-martial or Article 15 proceedings, because that would violate the service member’s Fourth Amendment rights against unreasonable search and seizure. However, urinalysis test results can be used to administratively separate a service member, so long as they are not used to characterize his or her type of discharge.

Troops whose urinalyses come back hot shortly after they voluntarily sought substance abuse treatment may have protection from government attempts to use such test results at UCMJ disciplinary proceedings, as long as their self-referral for treatment was legitimate. These urinalysis results can be used as a basis to separate service members in this situation, but the member cannot receive a discharge characterization below honorable.

Regardless of any self-referral, positive urinalysis test results can be used to justify denial or revocation of a security clearance, and such actions can lead to separation proceedings. And, if service members continue abusing illegal drugs after they self-refer, subsequent urinalysis test results can be used against them at UCMJ or administrative disciplinary proceedings and to characterize their separation, according to DODI 1010.1.

The government also cannot use the results of a positive urinalysis when a service member has a valid prescription or in the rare instances where a safety investigator promises someone, such as a witness to a mishap, “confidentiality in exchange for evidence” in the context of a safety investigation.

Additionally, with the exception of positive urinalyses stemming from valid prescription drug use, the DoD instruction not bar the government “from using, as rebuttal, urinalysis testing data that shows the presence of controlled substances, although not in a concentration sufficient to meet the cutoff level.” In other words, if a service member claims he never used marijuana but his urinalysis shows trace amounts of tetrahydrocannabinol — not enough to trigger a positive result — the government can use this evidence to charge him with making a false official statement.

Mathew B. Tully is a veteran of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and founding partner of Tully Rinckey PLLC (www.fedattorney.com). Email questions to askthelawyer@militarytimes.com. The information in this column is not intended as legal advice.